Jun 24, 2014 the polluter pays principle ppp is an environmental policy principle which requires that the costs of pollution be borne by those who cause it. Jul 02, 2012 however, it is possible to implement the polluter pays principle through a socalled carbon price. The polluter pays principle stipulates that the person who damages the environment must bear the cost of such damage. Routledge handbook of international environmental law. The polluter pays principle ppp was first mentioned in the recommendation of the oecd of 26th may 1972 and reaffirmed in the recommendation of 14th november 1974. Many economists claim that much environmental harm is caused by producers who externalize the costs of their activities. Abstractthe polluter pays principle ppp was born out of the need to find a global strategy for pollution control that would make polluters bear the costs of pollution and ensure sustainable activities. This emerged at a hearing in the european parliament on tuesday 11 april. Environmental principles from the polluter pays and precautionary principles to the principles of integration and sustainability proliferate in domestic and international legal and policy discourse, reflecting key goals of environmental protection and sustainable development on which there is apparent political. You will find a detailed presentation of the package in the trainers guide for the principles of eu environmental law training package. The groundbreaking new directive, the result of discussions which started in the late 1980s, is the first eu law specifically based on the polluter pays principle set out in the ec treaty. This article traces the evolution of polluter pays principle ppp as an economic, ethical and legal instrument and argues that it has the potential of effecting global responsibility for adaptation and mitigation and for generating reliable funding for the purpose. Oct 17, 2017 other key elements of eu legal protection, the polluter pays, and the principle that preventative action should be taken to avert environmental damage, have also been ruled out in the bill as a.
Principles of international environmental law routledge. Apr 27, 2007 important eu legislation laying down liability rules for damage to the environment comes into force on 30 april. Since the early 1970s the polluter pays principle has been a dominant concept in environmental law. Justice brian j preston sustainable development law in the courts. After years of negotiations, environmental law regime in the eu in 1984. The draft environment principles and governance bill establishes the office for environmental protection the oep, making it mandatory for subsequent governments to present environmental improvement plans, and gives a statutory footing to international principles of environmental law such as the precautionary principle and the polluter pays. The polluter pays principle is one of the oldest principles of environmental law and also one of the most intuitive. For other goods, it is harder to define property rights. This case brings back into sharp focus the polluter pays principle. The polluter pays principle introduction the world commission on environment and development in its report, our common.
After all, making the polluter pay for its wrongs makes sense on both. Who is liable to pay for environmental damage suffered in the. Case law of the european court of justice on the polluter pays principle. Oct 29, 2010 this wideranging and comprehensive handbook examines recent developments in international environmental law iel and the crossover effects of this expansion on other areas of international law, such as trade law and the law of the sea. Candice stevens, interpreting the polluter pays principle in the trade and environment context 27 cornell intl l. The polluter should pay, that is the simple principle underpinning the environmental liability directive. Sep 27, 20 this work traces the history of the polluter pays principle the ppp in the early economic literature from 1920s. The polluter pays principle and the remediation of the land emerald. In environmental law, the polluter pays principle is enacted to make the party responsible for producing pollution responsible for paying for the damage done to the natural environment. The polluter pays principle ppp was first mentioned in the recommendation. For instance, a factory that produces a potentially poisonous. Further, access to the bibliography of legal instruments and other. Ivers on the potential increase in fraud and corruption during the covid19 crisis.
In other areas of eu law, the polluter pays principle is not applied to air or. The article begins with economists ac pigou, av kneese, and others, and proceeds through legal developments, including the 1968 draft declaration of principles on air pollution control by the committee of ministers of the. Liability directive ensures polluters pay important eu legislation laying down liability rules for damage to the environment comes into force on 30 april. May 11, 2018 the polluter pays principle and the supreme court of india, published by indian law institute. Uk withdrawal bill rips the heart out of environmental law. The european commission proposed new eu wide rules in may, 2018 to target the 10 singleuse plastic products most often found in europes coastal habitats, as well as lost and abandoned fishing gear. The polluter pays principle is a way of internalising the externality. The plan states, the polluter pays principle should be adopted whereby polluting industries and. Who is liable to pay for environmental damage suffered in the uk. Fitzgerald, the precautionary principle in international law. Inconsistency can only be claimed based on an equity interpretation of the polluter pays principle. This work traces the history of the polluter pays principle the ppp in the early economic literature from 1920s.
The concept is also consistent with the polluter pays principle. Principles of environmental law i the sustainable development principle ii the integration principle iiithe prevention principle ivthe precautionary principle v the polluter pays principle vithe proximity principle viithe victim pays principle mdeleh12 day 4 rev1 2. Muhammad munir has posted history and development of the polluter pays principle, an article tracing the history of the ofteninvoked principle in economic and legal thought. Based on an efficiency interpretation of the principle, consistency is demonstrated by emphasizing the economic impact of the opportunity costs of gratis allowances and the lump sum nature of the subsidy that is inherent to grandfathering. Polluter pays principle an overview sciencedirect topics. Case law of the european court of justice on the polluter pays principle provides guidelines for burden sharing and recovery of. The polluter pays principle ppp is an environmental policy principle which requires that the costs of pollution be borne by those who cause it. The precautionary principle and the polluter pays principle have been accepted as part of the law of the land. Uk withdrawal bill rips the heart out of environmental. More precisely, it discusses the general principles of subsidiarity and proportionality, integration and sustainable development, as well as the environmental principles, precaution, prevention, rectification at source and the polluter pays.
Interpretation of polluter pays principle ppp in india. The polluter pays principle is part of a set of broader principles to guide sustainable development worldwide formally known as the 1992 rio declaration. Mar 03, 2019 the polluterpays principle in eu law bold case law and poor harmonisation, in teischrift hanschristian bugge, oslo, 2012, pp. The polluter pays principle has received support from most countries of the organisation for economic cooperation and development oecd and from the european community ec. That polluters should pay the social and environmental costs of their pollution. As well discuss in future questions in this series, this imposes a charge on the emission of. The polluter pays principle does not only apply if there is a real pollution in terms of harm or damage to private property andor the environment. Press releases european union website, the official eu website. In environmental law, the polluter pays principle is enacted to make the party responsible for.
This undermines the harmonisation of the polluter pays principle as a principle of union law, and the harmonisation of environmental liability in relation to contaminated land of course, but it also does something more fundamental than that. Polluterpays principle in eu law the polluterpays principle in eu law bold case law and poor harmonisation, in teischrift hanschristian bugge, oslo, 2012, pp. A number of developing countries have recently extended this principle to create an obligation on the state to compensate the victims of environmental harm. The 16th commonwealth law conference, hong kong, 7 april 2009 d6. The polluterpays principle is a guiding principle at european and international levels, according to which the waste producers and the waste holders should manage the wastes in order to guarantee the.
Article 21 of the constitution of india guarantees protection of life and personal liberty. A polluterpays principle, as it is recognized in many pollutionrelated conventions, in the oecd and eu khan, 2015, would also lead to more sustainable production along the whole value chain. A property rights based polluter pays principle, if implemented, would solve many of these problems by enforcing existing property rights and providing principled guidance for the. Air quality and noise legislation environment european.
An amendment to the withdrawal bill will be debated in the house of commons tomorrow aimed at addressing two glaring omissions from the proposed legislation the precautionary and polluter pays principles. The european court of justice has contributed significantly to the development of the polluter pays principle. This chapter begins by defining the polluterpays principle as an economic rule of cost allocation whose source lies precisely in the theory of externalities, requiring the polluter to take responsibility for the external costs arising from his pollution. Polluter pays is also known as extended polluter responsibility epr. In the 1972 declaration of the united nations conference on the human environment in stockholm the principles. The ppp features prominently in several environmental laws and regulations in ssa countries. But the legal text is riddled with loopholes and is not being implemented uniformly across the eu. In international environmental law, it is mentioned in principle 16 of the 1992. Legal provisions related to polluter pays principle in india there is no direct implementation of polluter pa ys principle in indian law but there are some provisions in various acts which. This divergence threatens to undermine the coherence in reliance on the polluter pays. The polluter pays principle, by shyel trehan and shuva mandel. In france, the charter for the environment contains a formulation of the polluter pays principle article 4. Francais producteur et ppp le producteur read more. Economic goods have ownership, the owner has the right to sell it in the market.
The polluter pays principle and state aid for environmental. If someone has access to a river, they can sue a chemical firm if they create a cost of pollution. Many european directives refer to this principle, for instance as a basis for cost. The primary function of the principle is that it helps in allocating the costs and repairing the damage, between different stakeholders, for. Many european directives refer to this principle, for instance as a basis for cost recovery or liability. It makes the firmconsumer pay the total social cost, rather than just the private cost. Apr 12, 2017 ministers from the 15 member states, and environmental ngos, are concerned that a key clause added in the draft eu environmental liability proposal, would exempt polluters from the polluter pays principle if they comply with environmental permits. The polluter pays principle and state aid for environmental protection. In its original emergence the polluter pays principle aims at determining how the costs of pollution prevention and control must be allocated. We are saddened by the passing of international tribunal for the law of the sea itlos president emeritus, judge thomas a.
Liability legislation environment european commission. In ghana, the polluter pays principle was adopted in 2011. This principle underpins part 2a of the environmental protection act 1990 which now includes radioactive contaminated land by virtue of the radioactive contaminated land scotland regulations 2007. In essence, the unions interpretation of the polluter pays principle is not shared by the member states. The polluter pays principle, the oecds guiding principles, oecds environmental policies, the european union communities, programme of action, efficient environmental principle, internalization of external costs, externality, spillover costs. The environmental damage prevention and remediation regulations 2009 as amended by the environmental damage prevention and remediation england regulations 2015 the regulations implement the provisions of the environmental liability directive. History and evolution of the polluter pays principle. Everyone shall be required, in the conditions provided for by law, to contribute to the making good of any damage he or she may have caused to the environment. The polluter pays principle states that whoever is responsible for damage to the environment should bear the costs associated with it. Eu environmental law, international environmental law, and. British institute of international and comparative law the european commission has acknowledged and respected, in regulation 12003, the ability of the member states to apply stricter rules than article 82. The groundbreaking new directive, the result of discussions which started in the late 1980s, is the first eu law specifically based on the polluter pays principle set out in.
The polluters pays principle is the commonly accepted practice that those who produce pollution should bear the costs of managing it to prevent damage to human health or the environment. It is regarded as a regional custom because of the strong support it has received in most organisation for economic cooperation and development and european union countries. This book addresses environmental damage, environmental harm, the grounds for environmental responsibility. It is regarded as a regional custom because of the strong support it has received in most organisation for economic cooperation and development oecd and european union countries. Characteristics of environmental goods environmental goods are public goods. The polluter pays principle and the supreme court of india, published by indian law institute. Since the 1960s, following the publication of rachel carsons book silent spring 7. This principle underpins most of the regulation of pollution affecting land, water and air. Environmental law principles, such as the polluter pays, the precautionary principle or the common but differentiated responsibilities, have had a very important function in the shaping and evolution of the young sector of environmental law which has developed over the last fifty years.
Article 47, 48a and 51ag of the constitutional are as under. The book is split into six parts for ease of reference. Application of the polluter pays and the producer responsibility principle in other areas of eu environmental law. Polluter pays principle is a globally well recognized and a much celebrated environmental law principle. Liability preliminary reference on environmental liability and the polluter pays principle. The polluter pays principle was recognised as a general principle of international environmental law in the 1990 international convention on oil pollution, preparedness, response and cooperation. Polluterpays principle an overview sciencedirect topics. The european community took up the oecd recommendation in its first. Rosso grossman, agriculture and the polluter pays principle. The rise and fall of the polluterpays principle in. The polluter pays principle as it is currently being advocated ends up being a wealth transfer from nonpolluters to politically well connected nonvictims.
The case of environmental responsibility, armelle gouritin offers a critical appraisal of eu environmental responsibility law and asserts a new rightsbased approach to international environmental law. The polluter pays principle and the eu state aid law for environmental protection, by keloniki pouilki, published in journal of law, policy and globalization, vol. This chapter introduces the principles important to european environmental law. Eu environment policy rests on the principles of precaution, prevention and rectifying pollution at source, and on the polluter pays principle. Polluter pays principle law and legal definition uslegal.
In the environmental law, the polluter pays principle refers to the principle that if pollution occurs, the person or organization that causes pollution should pay for the consequences of the pollution and for avoiding it in future. Brexit bill will rip the heart out of environmental. One of the main aims of this directive is, indeed, to help the european union to be closer to a recycling society european union, 2008. Polluter pays principle prof prabha panth, osmania university 2. The oecd recommended the ppp as the guiding principle concerning the international economic aspects of environmental policies in 1972. The precautionary principle is a risk management tool that may be invoked when there is scientific uncertainty about a suspected risk to human health or to the environment emanating from a certain. Oecd ilibrary is the online library of the organisation for economic cooperation and development oecd featuring its books, papers and statistics and is the gateway to oecds analysis and data. About environmental principles and the evolution of environmental law. Directive 200435ec of the european parliament and of the council of 21 april 2004 on environmental liability with regard to the prevention and remedying of environmental damage eld establishes a framework based on the polluter pays principle to prevent and remedy environmental damage. The polluter pays principle is set out in the treaty on the functioning of the european union.
In international environmental law, it is mentioned in principle 16 of the 1992 rio declaration on environment and development. Polluter pays principle in eu law the polluter pays principle in eu law bold case law and poor harmonisation, in teischrift hanschristian bugge, oslo, 2012, pp. The polluter pays principle requires either government intervention or the presence of clearly defined property rights. The precautionary principle is a part of eu law, but it has been also included in virtually. In the light of the precautionary principle, environmental legislation may also provide for measures which are taken to. Polluter pays principle trade v environment in eu law. This book addresses the application of the polluter pays principle to agricultural activities in a number of nations in the eu and north america. It is a fundamental principle in us environmental law.
If mps fail to vote for the change, the bill will rip the heart out of the uks environmental protections, warns green mep keith taylor. Agriculture and the polluter pays principle book, 2009. Other key elements of eu legal protection, the polluter pays, and the principle that preventative action should be taken to avert environmental damage, have also been ruled out in the bill as a means to protect the natural world from damage by policymakers, development or industry after brexit. They previously published addressing corruption allegations in. Polluter pays principle in eu law the polluter pays principle in eu law bold case law and poor harmonisation, in teischrift. It was developed as a followup to the xviith congress of the international academy of comparative law utrecht, the netherlands, july 2006. It has taken almost 20 years, but the european parliament finally reached agreement on a groundbreaking environmental liability directive earlier this year.
367 137 593 439 228 1480 1457 1077 162 1122 1510 1363 181 536 90 133 332 443 333 1038 834 647 89 17 981 934 578 633 863 316 719 187 1213 235 35 1184 14 600 233 444 892 189 394